Arguments for and against accounting standards. Accounting Awareness (AA): Arguments for and against Accounting Standards 2019-02-10

Arguments for and against accounting standards Rating: 4,8/10 634 reviews

Need for Harmonisation as a Reason for International Differences in Financial Reporting

arguments for and against accounting standards

Create a common legal framework for securities and derivatives markets are integrated 3. It will not ever exist. Today, with great variability between societies and cultures, moral relativism is greatly accepted as a matter-of-fact, but this is not necessarily the case. We need to be a leader and the driving force in establishing and adopting international standards. However, some also believe that the adoption merely result in disadvantages. Maybe the answer lies in the need to consider a more in-depth study and an examination of the factors influencing the molding or development of a country's accounting system.

Next

The Pros and Cons of Adopting IFRS

arguments for and against accounting standards

On criticism of International Standards Internationalization of accounting standards is also drawn criticism. When talking about accounting, the first thing we should know is. For the Single Market there can be no doubtthat everything must be done to lower the cost of capital, to increase investment and to reduce unemployment. Some penentusn says concerning that international accounting standards is a very simple solution for complex problems. However, this is almost impossible to achieve.

Next

Arguments Against Regulation Of Financial Reporting Free Essays

arguments for and against accounting standards

From a legal perspective, companies will be required to disclose qualitative and quantitative information about contracts with customers, including a maturity analysis for contracts extending beyond a year, as well as the inclusion of any significant judgments and changes in judgments made in applying the proposed standard to those contracts. The quality will suffer since compromises have to be made to achieve consensus due to various political pressures and economic interest. For example, in developing countries where there is little to no emphasis on the accounting profession, harmonization will be costly. Moreover, although there is a certain degree of legitimacy in the claim that obligatory voting serves to augment the democratic ideals of equality and participation, compelling a person to vote is ultimately, according to academic. The arguments are being made on a number of different grounds so be clear to separate these out. Accounting keeps the record of all financial reports which is very important for all the managers and stake holders like share holders, creditors or owners. Unfortunately, by the time the practice was abandoned in the United States.

Next

Argument Against Harmonization Essay Example

arguments for and against accounting standards

How did that fear of litigation work with Tyco, WorldCom, HealthSouth, etc. If harmonisation can contribute to these objectives by facilitating the access of European companies to the capital market, there is a lot to say in favour of such harmonisation. Comparing these arguments against regulation in accounting with the investor confidence, standard definitions and accepted understandings, benchmark comparisons and fraud minimisation that accounting regulation gives to business and the economy, it's easy for me to see why the consensus has been to maintain accounting regulation as a cornerstone of capitalist societies. This will result in an increase of and international investments, which will further reduce interest rates and lead to economic growth for a specific nation and the firms with which the country conducts business. Moreover, companies operating in different countries also can use their expertise and systems in all countries they are operating due to consistency of the reporting standards.

Next

Argument For And Against Accounting Regulation Free Essays

arguments for and against accounting standards

Many organizations have emphasized this need bringing about several attempts at constructing an international set of standards. A principles-based system requires companies to report and auditors to audit the substance or business purpose of transactions. Due to different sets of financial reporting standards, the way financial statements prepared and presented are different from each other which make it complicated to compare them. However, rule-based systems can rarely be water-tight. Efforts to harmonize accounting standards have been started long before the establishment of the International Accounting Standards Committee in 1973.

Next

Argument against the case an accounting standard to regulate the way in which complex financial instruments are reported in the financial statements of quoted companies essays

arguments for and against accounting standards

Capitalism, Economics, European Union 1681 Words 5 Pages raised by the transformation from U. To encourage the use and application of these standards are strict. The cost of an accounting system within a multinational is increased both by the cost of designing and running different accounting systems in different countries, and the cost of adjusting accounts from different countries to the accounting system of the country of the holding company for consolidation purposes. According to a study, under certain conditions, real earnings management increases as standards become tighter or more rules based this is because auditors are less likely to challenge structured transactions when accounting standards are more precise. Another disadvantage of harmonization is when there exists different economic environment as harmonization could be considered useless. For the past ten years, the financial instruments issued by companies have become more and more complex.


Next

International Harmonisation Of Accounting

arguments for and against accounting standards

The main issues with convergence lie with the difference in the approach of the U. These are just a few of them: 路 European Union 路 International Organization of Securities Commissions 路 International Federation of Accountants 路 World Trade Organization 路 International Monetary Fund 路 World Bank Advantages of Harmonization The first and most important advantage of harmonization of reporting standards is to achieve comparability in financial statements. It is designed to permit. Since the death penalty was re-instated in 1976, 1184 convicts have been executed in the United States, more than 5,000 since 1930. Therefore, the adoption is unexpected and controversial. The corporate governance system needed to be overhauled. There is some opposition to the convergence from all stakeholders involved, including accounting professionals s, etc.

Next

Argument Against Harmonization Essay Example

arguments for and against accounting standards

I have been told I do not deserve equal rights. Examining those dimensions and factors that impact an accounting system, it becomes evident that cultural differences have a strong impact on the accounting standards of another nation, thus complicating the standards convergence. It may only be able to meet the need of the person that wants rice. This is a question that I have never thought too deeply about because given all the facts about the advantages and disadvantages of regulation in accounting, I have always felt that the advantages far outweigh the disadvantages. Regulators may find themselves constantly lagging behind the avoidance activities of the regulatees McBarnet, 1988. At the same time, the process will provide for more credible information and will be simplified without the need for conversion to the standards of the country.

Next

International Harmonisation Of Accounting

arguments for and against accounting standards

There may be gaps in the rules, and places where the rules are vague or even incomplete. Accountants will be obligated to pursue a higher education to fulfill the requirements that will follow the standardization of accounting. And the strongest capital markets see the ability to accept International Accounting Standards as enabling them to compete more effectively: the need to prepare extra accounts to have a cross-border about the desirability of allowing domestic companies to use international standards for domestic companies may be content with the stock exchange quotations in other countries and see no need for a quotation on the domestic exchange. Will this agency be part of a government or will it be privately controlled? There are various reasons for such resistance to change, and some are pertinent to the accounting profession, some to corporate management and some are shared by both. Accounting harmonisation isan important issue. Mr Leuz works as a professor of International Economics at University of Chicago Booth School of Business. The importance of international accounting harmonization is now widely accepted for several reasons Alexander and Nobes 2008.

Next

Arguments Against Regulation Of Financial Reporting Free Essays

arguments for and against accounting standards

It is hence argued that, the use of the standards may not produce a statement that can meet these varied needs. Reed would need to locate some legal and ethical ways to report this transaction on any of the financial reports. Member states may extend this provision to the financial statements of companies that do not keep records of individual stocks and companies. It focuses on deceptive, unfair, and misleading advertisements. Arguments for euthanasia and assisted suicide There are two main types of argument used to support the practices of euthanasia and assisted suicide. Harmonization also takes away a sense of nationalism for some people.

Next